Tuesday 24 January 2012

Watch out bacterial pathogens!

A review of: Selvin, J., Manilal, A., Sujith, S., Kiran. G.S., Lipton, A.P. (2011). Efficacy of marine green alga Ulva fasciata extract on the management of. Latin American Journal of Aquatic Research. 39 (2), 197-204

11 species of Vibrio are commonly recognised as members of the normal bacterial flora of shrimp culture systems. However some of these members such as V. alginolyticus and V. harveyi pose serious threats as opportunistic pathogens and have been known to have a serious impact on the shrimp production industry. Marine secondary metabolites, from a number of different sources, have been recognised in previous studies as promising agents in shrimp disease management. The marine algae Ulva fasciata is found on the southwest coast of India amongst diverse variety of seaweed species. This highly competitive environment would insure that this alga’s secondary metabolites are highly reactive. The aim of this study was to establish the effect and the efficacy of U. fasciata based feed on the survival of shrimps experimentally infected with a range of pathogens.
They initially found the found the Lethal dose (LD) value of the pathogens: V. fischeri, V. alginolyticus, V. harveyi and Aeromonas sp. They intramuscularly injected samples of shrimp with the pathogens and then observed the effects. They increased the dose until total mortality was observed. A control group was injected with saline solution. They then top-coated commercially formulated shrimp feed with varying quantities of U. fasciata extracts 500mg, 1000mg and 1500mg/ kg of shrimp. Different groups shrimp were fed with U. fasciata diet for 15 days prior to being injected with the LD of the different pathogens. Again they used a control group which was not given U. fasciata in their diet to compare results. The diets were continued for 15 days after they were inoculated with the pathogens and a number of physiological and behaviour features were observed.
Shrimp fed with 500mg had the lowest protection against bacterial infection. Shrimp fed with 1000mg showed the highest level of protection in comparison to the other doses. They found that the survival of treated shrimp against the bacterial infection was significant at P<0.01. They found 100% mortality in the control shrimps even before the lethal dose, found in the preliminary experiments, was met. They believed this could be due to enhanced virulence obtained by the pathogenic isolates passed through the host, prior to in captivity control experiments. The median lethal dose of algal extract was determined to be 1120mg which is most likely the reason why there is a higher percentage of infection in the group of shrimps treated with 1500mg of U. fasciata. In an earlier study it was observed that pathogens were cleared off from the shrimp’s haemolymph within an hour in groups treated with U. fasciata. This suggests that the secondary metabolites of the algae stimulate the rapid response of bactericidins inside the shrimps. This study presents a promising development in bacterial pathogen management using natural marine products. The extracts can be stored in a dry form for long periods and this coupled with how easy it is to extract the bioactive ingredients makes it a low cost solution. Algae can be cultured in large quantities making its secondary metabolites not only eco-friendly but sustainable too. The large number of similar studies recently published is not surprising considering that this multimillion pound industry can be so easily threaten by things that are so hard to see.

6 comments:

Natasha Sprague said...

Hi,
I was just wondering whether the paper said anything about why the bacteria responded so negatively to the algaes secondary metabolites? Were they toxic to the bacteria, therefore killing them off like an antibiotic or was it something else happening? Really interesting and great solution to an aquaculture problem!

Arainna said...

Hey dave!
I found your review quite interesting and easy to read, and it is the first time I've heard about secondary metabolites from algae being utilised against pathogens. It seems like a good idea to use something that is naturally present in the environment, but I can't help thinking that with the rapid survival adaptation which Vibrio's seem to display that it wont be long before they adapt if certain species haven't already. Was there any mention of bacteria present in the natural algal environment displaying resistance to these secondary metabolites?

Dave Flynn said...

Hey Natasha
The paper doesn't have a lot of information on the mode of action of the algal extracts however it does briefly mention that it has been found to be a potent immunomodulator. A previous study showed that it stimulates a rapid immune response in shrimp producing bactericidins from haemocytes. So it seems it has a direct effect on the shrimp not the pathogenic bacteria. Fascinating!

Hey Arainna glad you liked the post. The vibrio's ability to adapt might not be so important with this form of control because it appears that the algal extracts do not directly interact with the bacteria. There was not any mention of resistance in the natural habitat although this does not mean it doesn't happen. If these vibrios are pathogenic to the algae then I would assume there would be an "arms race" scenario occurring.

Arainna said...

The "arms race" scenario you have mentioned seems quite logical, It would be interesting to see if in a cultured environment, away from environmental selection pressures, they would be able to continue evolving effective methods against any bacteria which develop resistance in the so called "arms race". I'm not quite sure what you mean about not reacting directly with the algae, as bactericidins are part of the organisms immune response. Do you remember Colin talking about the epizootics which devastated French aquaculture? Well this was suprising because mollusks have bactericidal activity in their haemolymph, but Vibrio splendidus (and related species)is resistant and this resistance mechanism has been put down to an enzymatic reaction. If you wanted to read more its talked about in Colins book (P229).

Dave Flynn said...

Yeah it would be interesting to see the effects of selection pressures in a cultured environment over a long-term.
Yes bactericidins are a part of the organisms immune response but from what I gather from this article the algal extracts work by stimulating the shrimps immune response so they are more effective at resisting the bacterial pathogens.

Arainna said...

ah I see what you mean, sorry I was getting a bit confused. All in all its quite an interesting research area!