Friday, 13 January 2012

Lactobacillus rhamnosus will make Nemo stronger!

A Review of : Matteo A Avella, Ike Olivotto, Stefania Silvi, Allen R. Place, and Oliana Carnevali
Effect of dietary probiotics on clownfish: a molecular approach to define how lactic acid bacteria modulate development in a marine fish
Am J Physiol Regul Integr Comp Physiol February 2010 298:(2) R359-R371; doi:10.1152/ajpregu.00300.2009

Probiotics are well known to have a positive effect on fish welfare by reducing general stress response and promoting growth.
This research team focused on the potential use of the lactic acid bacterium Lactobacillus rhamnosus as a probiotic for the clownfish Amphirion ocellaris development and growth.
To this purpose they supplied the L. rhamnosus to clownfish larvae and evaluated the response to probiotic treament through:
  • morphometric measurements such as total length and body weight
  • molecular measurements of gene expression (real-time PCR) of the biomarkers for:
GR (glucocorticoid receptor strongly correlated with cortisol, the most important index of primary stress response);
IGFs (insuline-like growth factors);
MSTN (myostatin);
HSP70 (heat shock protein as index of stress);
some nuclear receptors such as PPARs (peroxisome proliferator-activated receptors), VDRs (vitamin D receptors)and RARs (retinoid acid receptors) which are known to be important modulators for achieving optimal growth,correct development and proper pigmentation in marine fish.

Briefly, larvae were divided into three experimental groups and fed as follow:
  1. in the control group probiotics were not supplied to larvae
  2. in the group 2 probiotics were supplied from day 1 post-hatching twice a day via live prey (incubating rotifers and Artemia nauplii in probiotic water) and added to the rearing water
  3. in group 3 probiotics were supplied from day 1 post-hatching twice a day via live prey only
Results obtained were great!
Probiotic treatment was able to accelerate development since both in group 2 and 3 metamorphosis occured 3 days earlier than in the control group. Further, body weight of larvae and juveniles was significantly higher in animals supplied with probiotics, while the standard length increased only in juveniles.
The morphometric measurement were supported by changes in transcript abundance for the various biomarkers. A significant reduction was observed in the stress biomarker GR in both groups treated with L. rahmnosus and HSP70 transcripts levels showed a similar response. A significant increase was observed in IGFs, PPARs, VDRs and RARs , whereas MSTN levels decreased, supporting the extreme positive effects of probiotic to development and growth processes.
Clownfish treated with probiotic showed a significantly lower level in skeletal abnormalities compared to the control group, although the hystological section showed deformation of the skull (but not along vertebral column, as usually occurs).

Concluding, L. rahmnosus can significantly improve the clownfish welfare in terms of survivorship, growth and development, especially when the probiotic is supplied via live prey and added to the rearing water.

I think this study is very useful because of the implications in marine aquaculture. Using probiotic can prevent diseases usually affecting fishes in farming, especially in extremely livestock, where the high density of animals per tank has tremendous results on the whole reproduction process and on the organoleptic and nutritional properties of animals sold.
I am really impressed by the findings of this investigation, even because of 2 figures provided in the paper showing the great effectiveness of using probiotics in enhancement fish welfare.


4 comments:

valentina sciutteri said...

Sorry for the layout!I have always problems!
I tried to upload the images but I was not able,I strongly suggest you to see them if you are very interested in this topic!

Alice Anderson said...

Did the suggest how the , L. rahmnosus improved all this? For example was the probiotic releasing vitamins or inhibiting pathogens and that in turn reduced stress on the fish? Thisprobiotic strain has also been tested on rainbow trout. It increases the immune activity by stimulating complement activity and much more. It has been shown to increase survival by 81% when the fish are challenged with Aeromonas salomonicida. I have papers on this if your interested.

valentina sciutteri said...

Well, the hypothesis tested was that probiotic administration during early life stage could improve larval vitality through early maturation of the gastrointestinal tract,and results obtained actually confirmed this. The most positive effect was related to administration via live prey and addition to rearing water, perhaps because of the better retention of the probiotic itself by animals. Authors suggest that "L. rhamonsus", as a probiotic,is supposed to deliver to intestinal mucosal cells several molecules such as proteins,mineral salts,free fatty acids and vitamins useful for development,growth and general welfare of the host organism, although it is still unclear whether it provides growth-promoting factor accelerating clownfish development in this study.
Regarding this matter they hypothesize that the way of acting of "L. rhamnosus" on clownfish growth was similar to what they previously suggested for the European sea bass.

I know many bacteria are currently used as probiotics in different species of fishes to improve their welfare. "L. rhamnosus" was oringinally intended for human use. I wonder why if the positive effect in humans and teleosts occurs through the same pathways and, if so,if this happens because of similarities between humans and teleosts or because the capability of bacteria to adapt themselves to different hosts. I am thinking about this because I know that the zebrafish "Danio rerio" is a widely used model organisms not only because of the easiness of keeping it in lab and manipulating it but also because of its similarity to humans.
Considering the wide distribution of bacteria in varied environments (reflecting their great adapting ability) I would not be surprised by the fact that the same probiotic can positively acts in different hosts.


Here the paper of the same research team on the effect of probiotic on the European sea bass!!
Enjoy it!

Carnevali, O., L. de Vivo, et al. (2006). "Growth improvement by probiotic in European sea bass juveniles (Dicentrarchus labrax, L.), with particular attention to IGF-1, myostatin and cortisol gene expression." Aquaculture 258(1–4): 430-438.

Alice Anderson said...

thanks thats all very interesting. In what way is the zebra fish similar to humans? fish have very different conditions in the gut, i thought, because there is more of a flow of water flushing it out and therefore it is harder for bacteria to colonize, although i may have miss understood that. I get the feeing that probiotic experimentation is still in its early days and therefore scientists are testing anything that has been shown to help at some point including human probiotics on fish!